# Fileset

[20240721MSEA-D-24-02970_R1-clean.pdf](https://mdr.nims.go.jp/filesets/e31731d6-e41a-43e1-9c25-9aa55908b901/download)

## Creator

S.J. Liang, [S. Matsunaga](https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7285-5372), [Y. Toda](https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8343-2890), [Y. Yamabe-Mitarai](https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9674-5503)

## Rights

[Creative Commons BY-NC-ND Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)

## Other metadata

[Microstructure evolution by thermomechanical processing and high-temperature mechanical properties of HCP-high entropy alloys (HEAs)](https://mdr.nims.go.jp/datasets/8ddfe41d-074e-45c6-8fab-eb3481bb0346)

## Fulltext

Microstructure evolution by thermomechanical processing and high-1  temperature mechanical properties of HCP-high entropy alloys (HEAs) 2  S.J.Liang a, S. Matsunaga a, Y. Toda b, Y. Yamabe-Mitarai a\* 3  &#32;4  a Department of Advanced Materials Science, Graduate School of Frontier Sciences, The 5  University of Tokyo, 5-1-5 Kashiwanoha, Kashiwa City, Chiba 277-8561, Japan 6  b National Institute for Materials Science, 1-2-1 Sengen, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305-0047, 7  Japan 8  &#32;9  \*Corresponding authors’ email: mitarai.yoko@edu.k.u-tokyo.ac.jp 10  &#32;11  Keywords: HCP-HEAs, Thermomechanical processing, Equiaxed HCP phase, High 12  temperature strength, Deformation mechanism 13  &#32;14  Abstract 15  The solid solution strengthening and deformation mechanisms of the hcp-high entropy 16  alloys (HEAs) have not been elucidated yet because of the complexity introduced by the 17  martensite structure, particularly in alloys undergoing phase transformation from bcc to 18  hcp structures. This study attempted to fabricate an equiaxed hcp microstructure for 19  TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and TiZrHfAlSc using the hot rolling process and subsequent heat 20  treatment. The equiaxed hcp phase was successfully formed in TiZrHfAl, but the 21  martensite structure remained in TiZrHf and TiZrHfAlSc. The 0.2 % proof stress at 400 22  and 600°C increased with the increase of the average atomic size misfit δ and the mixing 23  entropy ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥. The low activation volume and high-stress exponent of TiZrHfAl with 24  equiaxed hcp phase at room temperature suggest minor obstacles such as cluster or short-25  range order inhibit the movement of dislocation and leading to the significant solid-26  solution strengthening. However, the effect diminished at 600 °C.  27  &#32;28  1\. Introduction  29  High-temperature (HT)-titanium alloys are widely used as heat-resistant materials in 30  fan blades and compressor components of aircraft jet engines, due to their lightweight, 31  excellent strength, and other corrosion resistance at high temperatures \[1,2\]. Despite their 32  lightweight, excellent strength, and high-temperature corrosion resistance, the 33  applications of current high-temperature (HT) titanium alloys are limited by their 34  degradation in mechanical properties such as high-temperature strength, fatigue strength, 35  creep, and oxidation resistance, especially when exposed to environments above 600°C 36  Revised Manuscript - clean version Click here to view linked References[mailto:mitarai.yoko@edu.k.u-tokyo.ac.jp](mailto:mitarai.yoko@edu.k.u-tokyo.ac.jp)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/viewRCResults.aspx?pdf=1\&docID=146780\&rev=1\&fileID=3536974\&msid=8968652f-20e6-4458-8b68-5da607641bc1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/viewRCResults.aspx?pdf=1&docID=146780&rev=1&fileID=3536974&msid=8968652f-20e6-4458-8b68-5da607641bc1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/viewRCResults.aspx?pdf=1\&docID=146780\&rev=1\&fileID=3536974\&msid=8968652f-20e6-4458-8b68-5da607641bc1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/viewRCResults.aspx?pdf=1&docID=146780&rev=1&fileID=3536974&msid=8968652f-20e6-4458-8b68-5da607641bc1)\[3\]. These properties are critical for jet engine applications, where exposure to high 37  temperatures is required. Hence, developing advanced HT-titanium alloys is necessary to 38  improve heat resistance, which can withstand extreme conditions while maintaining their 39  mechanical properties. However, the demands for higher operating temperatures and 40  improved mechanical properties have led to exploring alternative high-temperature 41  materials, including high-entropy alloys (HEAs) \[4\].  42  HEAs represent a unique class of materials consisting of multiple elements with near-43  equiatomic composition and high configurational entropy of their constituent elements 44  \[4\]. These fascinating materials have attracted significant interest in recent years due to 45  their potential to exhibit superior mechanical properties compared to conventional alloys. 46  This is attributed to their specific strengthening mechanism \[5\]. By incorporating multiple 47  elements into the alloy, the solid solution strengthening effect can be enhanced, which 48  may lead to improved high-temperature strength and stability \[6\]. Therefore, hcp-HEAs 49  are also expected to improve the solid solution strengthening of current high-temperature 50  alloys such as hcp-Ti alloys. However, the published research on HEAs has mainly 51  concentrated on fcc-type alloys such as CoCrFeNi \[7\] CoCrFeMnNi \[8\], AlCoCrFeNi \[9\], 52  and bcc-type alloys like NbMoTaVW \[10\], WTaFeCrV \[11\], HfNbTaTiZr \[12\]. The 53  research on the mechanical properties of the hcp-HEAs is limited \[6\].  54  In recent years, several studies have reported the successful fabrication of hcp-HEAs. 55  Initially, Takeuchi et al. \[13\],reported that nearly single hcp structures formed in 56  YGdTbDyLu and GdTbDyTmLu equiatomic alloys. However, the practical use of these 57  alloys is limited due to their high dependence on rare earth elements. Subsequently, a 58  growing number of hcp-TiZrHf HEAs have been reported, taking into account the 59  practical applications, for instance, TiZrHf \[14–16\], TiZrHfSc \[14\],\[16\],\[17\],\[18\], 60  TiZrHfY \[14\], AlHfScTiZr \[19\], TiZrHfYLa \[20\], ScYLaTiZrHf \[21\], ScTiZrHfRe \[22\]. 61  What’s more, despite some prior reports indicating that TiZrHfAl alloys formed a bcc and 62  194-Zr2Al phases \[16\],\[23\], the calculated phase diagrams for TiZrHfAl reported by 63  Nagase et al. \[23\], clearly indicate the hcp phase region in the temperature range below 64  1400 K. Consequently, the possibility of forming a stable hcp structure through heat 65  treatment in this temperature range is expected in TiZrHfAl. Based on these results, it can 66  be inferred that adding hcp-stabilizing elements such as Sc, Al, and Y to TiZrHf-based 67  alloys significantly stabilizes the hcp structure in HEAs. 68  &#32;These hcp-HEAs exhibit excellent mechanical properties. Huang et al., reported that 69  TiZrHf exhibited a yield strength of 773 MPa, whereas TiZrHfSc and TiZrHfY exhibited 70  a yield strength of 1001 and 554 MPa at room temperature, respectively \[14\]. This is 71  because Sc is solid-solution in TiZrHf, but Y is not solid-solution in TiZrHf and Y exists 72 interdendritic area between TiZrHf dendrite. Ł. Rogal et al. reported the strength of 73  TiZrHfScAl at room temperature was 1450 MPa \[19\]. Gan et al. reported that controlling 74  the ratio of Sc and Al in Ti25Zr25Hf25Sc(25−x)Alx had a certain effect on enhancing strength 75  and improving ductility \[24\]. However, among the limited research results available for 76  hcp-HEAs, the results focused on the martensite structure formed when the high-77  temperature bcc phase transforms into the low-temperature hcp phase \[14–16,19\]. These 78  specific martensite structures present a barrier to fully understanding the solid solution 79  strengthening and deformation mechanisms in hcp-HEAs. This is primarily due to their 80  inherently high strength, coupled with complex deformation behaviors, which 81  complicates this understanding. Consequently, isolating the influence of microstructure 82  is crucial for an effective analysis of solid solution-strengthening mechanisms in hcp-83  HEAs. In this context, it becomes indispensable to form equiaxed hcp phases. 84  Therefore, in this study, we aim to form an equiaxed hcp structure in HEAs, utilizing 85  thermomechanical processing and subsequent heat treatment. TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and 86  TiZrHfAlSc alloys, which stabilize the hcp structure, were selected and attempted the 87  formation of the equiaxed hcp phase by thermomechanical processing. The mechanical 88  properties of the obtained microstructure were investigated. Furthermore, a detailed 89  investigation was also conducted to elucidate the solid solution strengthening 90  mechanism of the TiZrHfAl alloy, which possesses an equiaxed hcp structure. 91  &#32;92  2\. Experimental procedure 93  2\.1 Alloy design 94  TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and TiZrHfAlSc were selected to form an equiaxed hcp structure. 95  In the previous study, it was observed that the TiZrHfAl formed Zr2Al precipitates in the 96  matrix. To inhibit the formation of precipitates, the composition of the matrix phase 97  obtained in the previous study, Ti29Zr23Hf27Al21 \[16\], was selected as the alloy 98  composition.  99  The mixing entropy, ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥, is defined by the following equation (1): 100  ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥 = −𝑅 ∑ 𝑥𝑖 ln 𝑥𝑖 𝑛 𝑖=1 &#32;   (1)  where R is the gas constant (8.314 J/(K·mol)) and 𝑥𝑖 is the atomic ratio of the i-th element. 101  The average atomic radius misfit 𝛿 is defined by the following equation (2): 102  &#32;103  𝛿 = 100√∑ 𝑥𝑖𝑖 • (1 − 𝑟𝑖 𝑟̅ ) 2 &#32;   (2)  where the 𝑟𝑖 is the atomic radius of ith element, and the 𝑟 ̅ is the average atomic radius. 104 The nominal compositions of the alloys are presented in Table 1. The mixing entropy, 105  ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥, the average atomic size misfit, δ, are also summarized in Table 1. According to 106  the strict definition of HEAs, TiZrHf and TiZrHfAl are classified as medium entropy 107  alloys. However, in this study, the wide definition of HEAs is used and we call TiZrHf 108  and TiZrHfAl as HEAs. 109  &#32;110  Table 1 The alloy composition, the mixing entropy (∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥), the average atomic size 111  misfit (δ) of the tested alloys 112  &#32; 113  Alloy Composition (Atom ratio)  (%)  ∆𝑺  (R)  𝜹  (%)  &#32;Ti Zr Hf Al Sc    TiZrHf 34 33 33 0 0 1.10 3.99  TiZrHfAl 29 23 27 21 0 1.37 4.70  TiZrHfAlSc 20 20 20 20 20 1.61 5.29  &#32;114  2\.2 Alloy preparation 115  Raw materials of Ti (purity of 99.9%, Furuuchi Chemical), Al (purity of 99.99%, 116  Furuuchi Chemical), Zr (purity of 99.9%, Furuuchi Chemical), Hf (purity of 99.7%, 117  Furuuchi Chemical), Sc (purity of 99.7%, Furuuchi Chemical), were weighed in the 118  appropriate amounts to attain the nominal composition as shown in Table 1. The 20g 119  ingots of the alloys with the nominal composition were prepared in an arc-melting furnace 120  with a water-cooled copper plate under a protective argon atmosphere. The alloys were 121  re-melted 5 times to ensure they were fully homogenized. Each drop shape ingot was 122  8mm in height and 10mm in diameter. Following this, the ingots were heated to 1000℃ 123  for 5 minutes in an air furnace and subsequently hot-rolled. Each rolling step involved a 124  reduction ratio of 10%, and after each rolling step, the sample was reheated at 1000 ℃ 125  for 5 minutes, culminating in a total reduction in thickness of 55%. 126  &#32;127  2\.3 Heat treatment 128  To promote the formation of equiaxed hcp phases in the alloys, the heat treatment 129  temperature was decided by thermodynamic calculation using Thermo-Calc© software 130  2022a with the TCTI3 database. As Sc was not included in the TCTI3 database, the alloys 131  without Sc were calculated and presented in Fig. 1. According to the isothermal sections 132  of the TiZrHf alloy and the phase diagram of the TiZrHfAl, the major potential phases in 133  different temperature regions are summarized in Table 2. The TiZrHf alloy exhibits the 134  single hcp phase at temperatures ranging from 700 to 800 ℃ and the hcp + bcc two phases 135 at 900℃. The TiZrHfAl alloy also forms the hcp phase between 700 and 1000 ℃, 136  although the Al2Zr3 or Al3Zr5 phase also forms. Therefore, the heat treatment temperature 137  was decided at the temperature range from 700 to 900 ℃. The 3×3×3 mm sample was cut 138  from the rolled sample and enclosed with Ar gas in a quartz tube to prevent material 139  oxidation during heat treatment. The samples were subjected to heat treatment at 140  temperatures ranging from 700 to 900℃ for 24 or 168 hours, followed by either water 141  quenching or furnace cooling. 142  &#32;143  2\.4 Phase identification 144  The crystal structure of the heat-treated specimens was identified by X-ray diffraction 145  (XRD). The XRD analysis was performed on the equipment of RIGAKU Smartlab with 146  CuKα-radiation (λ = 0.154 nm) at the 2θ range of 10–90° with a scanning rate of 10°/min 147  and 0.02˚step at room temperature. The PDXL-2 (Rigaku) data analysis software and 148  ICDD PDF-4 international diffraction database were used to determine the crystal 149  structure of the phase.  150  The heat-treated specimens were embedded in conductive phenolic resin (S60PA-K10, 151  IMT Corporation). These mounted specimens underwent automated polishing using a 152  polishing machine (SP-200, Subtech, Inc.) with a sequence of Grit320, 400, 600, and 800 153  polishing papers, followed by 9 μm, 3 μm, 1μm polycrystalline diamond with silica 154  suspension, and finally received a final polishing with a 5:1 mixture of colloidal silica 155  and hydrogen peroxide solution. The polishing machine operated at 150 rotations per 156  minute, and a load of 0.5 MPa was applied during each step. The microstructure and phase 157  composition of the alloys were analyzed using field emission scanning electron 158  microscopy (FE-SEM, JEOL, JSM7200F) equipped with an energy-dispersive 159  spectrometer (EDS) and was operated at an accelerating voltage of 20 kV. 160  &#32;161 &#32;162  &#32;163  Fig. 1 The isothermal section of TiZrHf at (a) 700℃, (b) 800℃, (c) 900℃, (d) 1000℃, 164  and (e) phase diagram as a function of Al contents of TiZrHfAl. 165  &#32;166  Table. 2 The stable phase of the calculated by Thermo-Calc software in different 167  temperature regions  168  &#32;169  Alloy Temperature region  (℃)  The calculated stable  phase   &#32; TiZrHf  700 hcp  800 hcp  900 hcp+bcc  1000 bcc  &#32; TiZrHfAl  700 hcp+Al2Zr3  800 hcp+Al2Zr3  900 hcp+Al2Zr3  &#32;1000 hcp+Al2Zr3+ Al3Zr5  &#32;170  2\.5 Evaluation of mechanical properties 171  To evaluate the 0.2% proof stress, compression tests were performed on heat-treated 172  specimens with dimensions of 3×3×5 mm3 at 400 and 600 ℃ by using the high-173  temperature compression testing machine (Shimadzu AG-X). The initial strain rate was 174  set at 3×10-4/s. To investigate the deformation mechanism, strain rate jump tests were 175  carried out on TiZrHfAl at room temperature and 600 ℃, employing strain rates of 3×10-176  5/s, 3×10-4/s, and 3×10-3/s, respectively. At each step, the strain rate was maintained until 177  1-5% plastic strain was obtained, then moved to the next step. 178 3\. Results 179  &#32;180  3\.1 Phase analysis and microstructure 181  Fig. 2 displays the microstructure and Table 3 summarises the EDS chemical analysis 182  results of the as-rolled specimens. In the TiZrHf alloy, martensite structures measuring 2-183  3 μm in width were observed (Fig. 2(a-1)), while the TiZrHfAlSc alloy exhibited finer 184  martensite structures with widths of less than 1 μm, along with a finer dark equiaxed 185  phase (Fig. 2(c-1)). These martensite structures are consistent with those observed in as-186  cast specimens in other studies \[15,19\]. Additionally, elliptical black regions of 187  approximately 1 μm in width were observed in the TiZrHfAlSc alloy as marked in Fig. 188  2(c). The high concentration of Sc and O in these regions suggests they are likely oxides 189  of Sc, possibly introduced during the rolling process under atmospheric conditions. The 190  elemental distribution within the fine martensite and equiaxed structures in the matrix did 191  not show significant differences.  192  Most notably, the TiZrHfAl alloy exhibited a dark precipitated phase (Fig. 2(b)) and 193  an equiaxed dark structure composed of fine grains encased within a bright phase, as 194  evidenced in Fig. 2(b-1). EDS results suggest that these dark precipitated phases shown 195  in Fig. 2(b) are (Zr, Hf, Ti)2Al phases. It was observed that Ti and Hf contents are slightly 196  high in the bright phases in the matrix and Zr and Al contents are slightly high in the dark 197  phase. The presence of the dark precipitated phase is consistent with our previous findings 198  \[16\], suggesting that the alloy composition adjustment did not eliminate the presence of 199  precipitates although the volume fraction of precipitates drastically decreased. 200  &#32;201  &#32;202  &#32;203 &#32;204  &#32;205  Fig. 2 Backscattered images of the specimens rolled at 1000℃: (a) TiZrHf, with high 206  magnification (a-1), (b) TiZrHfAl, and high magnification of the matrix region marked 207  by the red line (b-1), (c) TiZrHfAlSc and high magnification of the matrix region marked 208  by the red line (c-1). 209  &#32;210  &#32;211  &#32;212  &#32;213  &#32;214  &#32;215  &#32;216  &#32;217 &#32;218  Table 3 Phase composition (at%) of as-rolled specimens investigated by EDS. 219  &#32;220  Alloy Region Ti Zr Hf Al Sc O  TiZrHf Martensite 32.7 33.1 34.2 - - -  &#32; &#32; TiZrHfAl  Dark  Precipitated  phases  16 26.3 23.8 33.9 - -  Dark phase 28.0 24.1 28.6 19.3 - -  Bright  phase  32\.2 21.0 29.0 17.8 - -  &#32; &#32; TiZrHfAlSc  Black  regions  12\.2 11.0 11.0 11.3 29.5 25.0  Fine  equiaxed  20\.1 20.4 18.0 20.2 21.3 -  Fine  martensite  21\.9 20.1 18.8 19.0 20.2 -  &#32;221  X-ray diffraction analysis was conducted for the heat-treated samples. The heat 222  treatment condition was 800 °C for 24 hours for TiZrHf and TiZrHfAlSc and 168 hours 223  for TiZrHfAl followed by furnace cooling. The XRD patterns are shown in Fig. 3. Intense 224  peaks of the hcp-phase (space group 194) are present in all three specimens, yet 225  distinctions exist among them. The TiZrHf specimen displays a single peak corresponding 226  to the hcp-phase with lattice constants of a = 3.15Å, c =5.03Å, and c/a=1.60. Notably, in 227  the TiZrHfAl specimen, the lattice constants were a = 3.05Å, c =4.86Å, and c/a=1.59. We 228  also identify peaks associated with hcp-Zr2Al, despite their subdued intensity. In the 229  TiZrHfAlSc specimen, the lattice constants were a = 3.11Å, c =4.93Å and c/a=1.59, 230  alongside the principal hcp-phase peaks, we discern additional faint unknown peaks. 231  In the microstructure of heat-treated samples depicted in Fig. 4 (a), the TiZrHf alloy 232  maintains its martensite structure like its as-rolled condition. It exhibits a notable growth 233  to plate-like structures with a width of 2-8 µm. Additionally, the coarse grain boundary 234  hcp-phase, with widths reaching up to 10 µm, is formed along the grain boundaries, as 235  depicted in Fig. 4(a, a-1). According to the results obtained from the chemical analysis by 236  EDS shown in Table 4, these plate-like hcp structures exhibit an elemental distribution 237  equal to the composition of the alloy.  238  On the other hand, in the TiZrHfAl alloy, three distinct microstructures were observed: 239  (region 1): a dark precipitated phase surrounded by bright phases, (region 2): a bright 240  phase formed along grain boundaries and dark precipitated phase, and (region 3, 4): a 241 comparatively fine equiaxed structure in the matrix as shown in Fig. 4 (b, b-1). ImageJ 242  analysis revealed that the dark precipitated phase has irregular shapes measuring 6 to 15 243  μm in length and 2 to 5 μm in width, constituting 6% of the total volume. Upon closer 244  examination of the fine matrix phase, it is composed of both dark and bright phases, each 245  with grain sizes around 1-3 μm and exhibiting an equiaxed morphology (Fig. 4 (b-1)). 246  EDS elemental analysis, as shown in Table 4, indicates that the bright phases formed 247  surrounding the dark precipitated phase (Region 2 in Fig. 5 (a)) are low in Al content, 248  14\.5 at%, compared with another phase. In contrast, the dark precipitates (Region 1 in 249  Fig. 5 (a)) show 33.2 at% of Al. The EBSD phase map distinctly demonstrates that the 250  bright phases (Region 1) are hcp phases (Fig. 6 (b)). Conversely, the dark precipitated 251  phase (Region 2) is identified as 194-Zr2Al. In the fine phases of the matrix, the 252  composition difference between the bright regions (Region 4 in Fig. 5 (b)) and the dark 253  phases (Region 3 in Fig. 5 (b)) is minimal, but the Hf contents in the bright phase are 1 254  at% higher than in the dark phase. This small difference in the Hf contents caused the 255  different contrast of the phases in Fig. 4 (b-1). Analysis of the XRD pattern in Fig. 3 and 256  the EBSD phase map in Fig. 6 (c) indicate these phases are hcp phases.  257  In the TiZrHfAlSc alloy, we observed the formation of a fine plate-like structure from 258  the fine martensite structure that had developed during the rolling process (Fig. 4 (c)), 259  consistent with other finding \[19\]. Even though these plates became coarser than those 260  observed in Fig. 2 (c-1), their thickness remained less than 1 µm. XRD pattern analysis 261  suggests that the plate-like structure is the hcp-phase. However, unlike in the TiZrHfAl 262  alloy, heat treatment eliminated the finer dark equiaxed phase within the matrix observed 263  in the as-rolled specimens. In addition, elliptical black particles were still observed (Fig. 264  4 (c, c-1)), as indicated by red arrows. EDS analysis revealed a high concentration of Sc 265  and O in these areas, suggesting the presence of Sc oxides introduced during the rolling 266  process, even though no specific peaks for these oxides were detected in the XRD pattern. 267  Oxides of Sc also appeared in other reports in TiZrHfSc \[16\] because the Sc was easily 268  oxidized and even the addition of Al could not prevent the oxidation of Sc. 269  These results show that the TiZrHf alloy developed a coarsened martensite structure 270  without any precipitates. In contrast, the TiZrHfAl alloy formed two hcp phases with 271  slightly different compositions, along with Zr2Al precipitates. Meanwhile, the 272  TiZrHfAlSc alloy displayed a fine plate-like hcp phase, and Sc2O3 precipitates. 273  &#32;274 &#32;275  &#32;276  Fig. 3 XRD patterns of the specimens (a) TiZrHf, (b) TiZrHfAl, (c) TiZrHfAlSc, after 277  heat-treatment at 800℃ for 24h and 168h followed by furnace cooling. 278  &#32;279 &#32;280  &#32;281  Fig. 4 Backscattered images of specimens heat-treated at 800℃ for 24h with furnace 282  cooling: (a) TiZrHf, with a high-magnification view (a-1), (c) TiZrHfAlSc, and high 283  magnification (c-1). Additionally, (b) TiZrHfAl and a high-magnification view (b-1) are 284  presented for specimens heat-treated at 800℃ for 168h followed by furnace cooling.  285  &#32;286 &#32;287  &#32;288  Fig. 5 Elemental analysis of designated regions in TiZrHfAl specimens after heat 289  treatment through EDS.  290  &#32;291  Table 4 Phase composition (at%) of alloys after heat treatment investigated by EDS. 292  &#32;293  Heat- treatment  condition  Alloy Region Ti Zr Hf Al Sc O Phase  800℃  24h  FC  &#32; TiZrHf  Plate-like  phase  &#32; 33\.5  &#32; 32\.6  &#32; 33\.9  \- - -   hcp  &#32; &#32; 800℃  168h  FC  &#32; &#32; &#32; TiZrHfAl  1 19.5 25.5 22.8 32.2 - - Zr2Al- 194  2 33.8 20.0 31.7 14.5 - - hcp  3 31.3 21.7 26.9 20.1 - - hcp  4 31.4 21.5 28.1 19 - - hcp  800℃  24h  FC  TiZrHfAlSc Dark 12.3 9.3 8.7 10.2 25.5 34 Sc2O3  &#32; Plate-like  phase  20\.2 19.6 18.9 16.3 16.4 8.6 hcp  &#32; &#32;294 &#32;295  &#32;296  Fig. 6 Electron Back Scatter Diffraction (EBSD) images of TiZrHfAl heat-treated at 297  800℃ for 168h with furnace cooling: (a) Image Quality (IQ) map focusing on the grain 298  boundary and precipitates, (b) Phase map of grain boundary and precipitates, (c) Phase 299  map of fine matrix region. 300  &#32;301  3\.2 Mechanical properties 302  Compression tests were performed on TiZrHf and TiZrHfAlSc alloy specimens, 303  which were heat-treated at 800°C for 24 hours followed by furnace cooling, and on 304  TiZrHfAl alloy specimens treated under the same temperature for 168 hours followed by 305  furnace cooling, to evaluate their high-temperature strength. As shown in Fig. 4, the 306  TiZrHf alloy exhibited a coarsened plate-like structure, the TiZrHfAlSc alloy revealed a 307  finer plate-like structure interspersed with ScO2. In contrast, the TiZrHfAl was 308  characterized by an equiaxed hcp phase with a Zr2Al precipitated phase. 309  Fig. 7 illustrate the 0.2% proof stress at 400 and 600 °C for the studied alloys. 310  Themixing entropy, ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥, and  parameters are also shown in Fig. 7. The TiZrHfAlSc 311  alloy exhibited  highest strength in the 400 and 600 °C, but it fractured during the elastic 312  deformation stage at 400 °C, which can be postulated that the 0.2% proof stress for this 313  alloy should be higher than what is indicated in Fig. 7. The 0.2% proof stress of TiZrHfAl 314  alloy was the secondary highest at 400 and 600 °C. The 0.2% proof stress of the TiZrHf 315  alloy was the lowest at 400 and 600 °C. Although the microstructures of these alloys are 316  different, the higher strength was shown in the alloy with larger ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥 and  parameters. 317  The 0.2% proof stress of the TiZrHfAlSc and TiZrHfAl were over 900 MPa at 600 ˚C, 318  higher than those of commercial Ti alloys such as TIMETAL 834 about 500 MPa \[25\]. 319 &#32;320  Fig. 7 0.2% proof stress of TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, TiZrHfAlSc specimens by compression 321  test at 400℃ and 600℃. 322  &#32;323  3\.3 Deformation behavior 324  To investigate the deformation mechanism of the equiaxed hcp structure, a 325  compression strain rate jump test was performed on the TiZrHfAl specimen heat-treated 326  at 800℃ for 168h followed by furnace cooling. The compressive stress-strain curves 327  obtained from the strain rate jump test at room temperature and 600℃ are shown in Figs. 328  8 (a) and (b), respectively. In the strain rate jump test, strain rate change causes a sharp 329  increase in stress \[26\]. As shown in Fig. 8, the stress jump was observed at each strain 330  rate change, except for the first strain rate change at room temperature, which was too 331  small to be observed. Based on these stress changes, the 0.2% proof stress corresponding 332  to each different strain rate at room temperature and 600℃ was measured and 333  summarized in Table 5.  334 &#32;335  &#32;336  Fig. 8 Stress and strain curves at (a) room temperature and (b) 600℃, by stain rate jump 337  test for TiZrHfAl alloy. 338  &#32;339  Table 5 The 0.2% proof stress corresponds to each different strain rate at room 340  temperature and 600℃. 341  &#32;342  Temperature  (℃)    0\.2% proof stress (MPa)  3×10-5 s-1 3×10-4 s-1 3×10-3 s-1  RT 1393 1395 1528  600 502 655 725  &#32;343  Like the investigation approach used to study the high-temperature deformation 344  mechanism of conventional titanium alloys, an Arrhenius-type equation was used to 345  express the strain rate 𝜀̇  \[27\]. 346  𝜀̇ = 𝐴𝜎𝑛𝑒𝑥𝑝 (− 𝑄 𝑅𝑇 )  (3)  where A is the material constant, 𝜎  is the stress,  n is the stress exponent, 𝑄  is the 347  activation energy for deformation, 𝑅 is a gas constant, and 𝑇 is the temperature.Taking 348  the natural logarithm of both sides gives: 349  ln 𝜀̇ = ln(𝐴) + 𝑛ln 𝜎 − 𝑄 𝑅 ( 1 𝑇 )  (4)  The stress exponent n can be calculated from the slope using a double logarithm plot of 350  ln 𝜀̇ and ln 𝜎 in equation (4). The 0.2% proof stress was used as 𝜎 to estimate the stress 351  exponent n. 352  The double logarithm plot of the strain rate 𝜀̇ and 0.2% proof stress 𝜎 at room temperature 353  and 600℃ are shown, as shown in Fig. 9. The stress exponent value was approximately 354 18 at room temperature and 5 at 600℃. It exhibited a large stress exponent at room 355  temperature, and the stress exponent at 600 °C was essentially the same as that of 356  conventional heat-resistant titanium alloys \[28\]. 357  &#32;358  &#32;359  Fig. 9 Double logarithm plot of the stress and strain rate of TiZrHfAl sample obtained 360  by strain rate jump test at RT and at 600℃. 361  &#32;362  High-temperature deformation is a thermally activated process, and the thermally 363  activated mechanisms of compressive deformation can be quantitatively expressed using 364  the activation volume, 𝑉∗ , defined as the volume that dislocation can move by 365  overcoming obstacles during deformation \[29\]\[30\]. The activation volume which is 366  normally expressed in a unit of b3 (b is the Burgers vector), 𝑉∗, is defined as the following 367  equation (5). 368  𝑉∗ = √3𝑘𝑇(𝜕𝑙𝑛𝜀̇ 𝜕𝜎⁄ ) (5)  where k is the Boltzmann’s constant, and the T is the absolute temperature. The activation 369  volumes were calculated and summarized in Table 6. As shown in Table 6 the activation 370  volume of TiZrHfAl increased with increasing temperature and strain rate, reaching 371  values of 15-35 b3 at 600℃. The activation volumes of pure Ti and Mg with hcp structures 372  and those of recently reported bcc high-entropy alloy TiZrHfNb were also summarized 373  for comparison in Table 6. It can be found that the activation volume of TiZrHfAl is 6.3 374 at room temperature, which is approximately the same order as 4 for TiZrHfNb of the 375  bcc-type high-entropy alloy in another study \[31\]. The activation volumes of TiZrHfAl at 376  600 ℃ were within the same range as those of Ti, Mg, and their alloys at room 377  temperature \[32–34\]. 378  &#32;379  Table 6 The activation volume measured from the strain rate jump tests at RT and 380  600℃ of the TiZrHfAl sample. 381  &#32;382  Temperature  (℃)  3×10-5   \~3×10-4   s-1  3×10-4   \~3×10-3  &#32;s-1  Pure  Ti \[32\]  Ti-6Al- 4V \[33\]  Pure Mg  \[34\]  &#32; BCC-HEA  TiZrHfNb  \[31\]  &#32;𝑽∗ (b3) 𝑽∗ (b3)  RT - 6.3 35 25 4.3  600 15.8 34.8 - - -  &#32;383  4\. Discussion  384  4\.1 Microstructure formation  385  In addition to TiZrHfAl, previous investigations have confirmed the presence of hcp 386  phases in TiZrHf and TiZrHfAlSc alloys\[14–16,19\]. However, the investigations were 387  performed for as-cast\[14,15\] or just heat-treated for homogenization\[16\]\[19\], and then 388  the observed microstructures in these alloys have primarily exhibited martensite and 389  plate-like structures. To achieve the equiaxed hcp structure, distinct from the prevailing 390  martensite microstructure, the appropriate manufacturing process is important. It is well 391  known that in the traditional titanium alloy, thermomechanical and subsequent heat 392  treatment in the α+β two-phase region can produce the equiaxed structure by 393  recrystallization assisted by dense dislocation density introduced during deformation. 394  \[35\]. 395  In this study, thermomechanical processing followed by heat treatment was conducted 396  on TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and TiZrHfAlSc alloys. As depicted in Fig. 4(b, b-1), the successful 397  formation of equiaxed hcp phases in the TiZrHfAl alloy was achieved. In the TiZrHfAl 398  alloy, the thermomechanical processing was conducted at 1000 ℃ in the hcp phase region. 399  The initial microstructure was broken during deformation and dynamic recrystallization 400  of the hcp phase occurred during subsequent reheating at 1000℃, as illustrated in Fig. 2 401  (b-1). Following heat treatment at 800 ℃ in the hcp phase region, these recrystallized 402  equiaxed grains grew and became more uniform. Although the phase diagram indicates a 403  single hcp phase, two hcp phases with small composition differences were formed. This 404 might occur in compositional fluctuation in HEAs. At 800℃, the phase diagram in Fig. 1 405  (e) suggests the formation of Al2Zr3 phases. However, Zr2Al phases were observed in our 406  experiment. This discrepancy indicates that the phase equilibria predicted by Thermo 407  Calc differed from the experimental results.  408  Conversely, the equiaxed structure was not formed in TiZrHf and TiZrHfAlSc. The 409  thermomechanical treatment temperature of 1000℃ is the bcc phase in TiZrHf, as shown 410  in Fig. 1(d). The martensite structure in the processed sample (Fig. 2 (a-1)) indicates that 411  the dislocations induced during rolling were released during reheating after rolling, and 412  then thermomechanical treatment did not affect breaking the martensite structure.  The 413  subsequent heat treatment at 800℃ in the hcp phase just coarsen the martensite structure. 414  A similar microstructure was obtained in TiZrHfAlSc, although the structure was finer 415  than in TiZrHf. The phase diagram of TiZrHfAlSc was not clear, but it is expected that 416  the bcc phase was stable at 1000 ℃ in TiZrHfAlSc. This also indicates that TiZrHf, 417  thermomechanical treatment was insufficient to introduce dislocations for accelerating 418  nucleation of the hcp phase during subsequent heat treatment. 419  &#32;420  4\.2 Mechanical properties 421  As shown in Fig. 7, the 0.2 % proof stress increased with the increase of the mixing 422  entropy, ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥  and the average atomic size misfit, δ. It is well known that solid-solution 423  strengthening in binary alloys with higher concentrations of solute atoms (𝑥𝑖) is shown in 424  equation (6) \[36\]. 425  ∆𝜎𝑠𝑠 = 𝐵𝑖𝑥𝑖 2/3 &#32;                                                  (6) 426  where the parameters 𝐵𝑖 is 427  𝐵𝑖 = 3𝜇𝜀𝑖 4/3 𝑍                                                  (7) 428  where 𝜇 is the shear modulus of the alloy and Z is a fitting constant. 429  The parameters 𝜀𝑖 is the sum of the elastic misfit 𝜂𝑖 ′ and the atomic size misfit 𝛿𝑖 between 430  two dissimilar atoms. 431  𝜀𝑖 = (𝜉𝜂𝑖 ′2 + 𝛼2𝛿𝑖 2\)1/2                                     (8) 432  where 𝜉 is related to the activated slip systems, and 𝛼 is the lattice parameter of the alloy. 433  From equation (6) \~ (8), the solid solution strengthening is proportional to 3/4 ths of the 434  atomic size misfit. 435  This equation was expanded to HEAs and expressed as the following equation (9) by 436  Gypen \[37\] and Toda-Caraballo \[38,39\].  437  𝜎𝑠𝑠 = (∑ 𝐵𝑖 3/2 𝑥𝑖𝑖 ) 2/3 ;  𝐵𝑖 = 𝑀𝜇𝜀𝑖 4/3𝑍              (9) 438  The solid solution strengthening is expressed by the sum of the effect of elastic misfit and 439 the atomic size misfit for all combinations of the constituent elements.  From equations 440  (8) and (9), the increase of the atomic size misfit 𝛿𝑖  increases the solid solution 441  strengthening. The average atomic size misfit 𝛿  in equation (2) is the average of all 442  combinations of the constituent elements and is different from the atomic size misfit 𝛿𝑖 443  where two dissimilar atoms are compared. However, if the sum of the atomic size misfit 444  𝛿𝑖  increases, the average atomic size misfit 𝛿  also increases. Then, an increase in the 445  average atomic size misfit 𝛿 causes an increase in the solid solution strengthening effect. 446  In our study, three alloys represented different microstructures, but they were consisted 447  of the hcp phase. The increase in the average atomic size misfit 𝛿 indicates an increase in 448  solid solution strengthening of the hcp phase. Then, it is reasonable that the strength of 449  the alloy with a higher 𝛿 was higher. 450  &#32;   To our knowledge, there is no explanation of the solid-solution strengthening effect 451  directly related to the mixing entropy ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥. However, an increase in the mixing entropy 452  indicates a high probability that atoms of different species will be next to each other. This 453  causes lattice distortion and increases the solid-solution strength together with the atomic 454  size misfit. Our experimental results support the effect of the mixing entropy on the solid 455  solution strengthening. 456  &#32;457  &#32;458  &#32;459  &#32;460  &#32;461  &#32;462  &#32;463  &#32;464  &#32;465  &#32;466  &#32;467  &#32;468  &#32;469  &#32;470  &#32;471  &#32;472  &#32;473  &#32;474  &#32;475 Table 7 Comparative analysis of 0.2% proof stress in TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, TiZrHfAlSc 476  alloys under compression at 400℃ and 600℃ concerning other studies. 477  &#32;478  &#32;479  &#32;480  Table 7 summarizes the microstructures and strengths investigated in the previous 481  studies to compare our results. The strength of the TiZrHf with the plate-like structure 482  was 900 MPa \[15\] at room temperature and 335 MPa at 600 ℃ in our study. The strength 483  of the TiZrHf with the martensite structure was 900 and 300 MPa at room temperature 484  and 600 ℃, respectively \[16\]. These results indicate that the strengths of TiZrHf were 485  similar values independent of microstructure, either the plate-like or martensite structures. 486  In addition, the TiZrHf alloys do not exhibit exceptional high-temperature strength 487  compared to conventional alloys, with a strength of approximately 500 MPa at 590 ℃ for 488  TIMETAL 834 \[25\].  489  For hcp-TiZrHfAl alloy, no strength data was found even at both room temperature 490  Alloy  composition  Process Microstructure Thick- ness  (μm)  Test  temperature  (℃)  𝜎𝑦  (MPa)  Ref.  &#32; &#32; &#32; TiZrHf  Rolled and  heat- treated  Plate-like  2-5 400 541 This  study 600 335  As-cast Plate-like  - RT 773 \[14\]  As-cast plate-like  2-5 RT 901 \[15\]  As-cast   + heat- treated  Martensite - RT 900 \[16\]  600 300  TiZrHfAl Rolled and  heat- treated  Equiaxed-hcp  with Zr2Al  1 400 967 This  study 600 928  As-cast  &#32;+ heat- treated  Bcc with Zr2Al - 600 1000 \[16\]  &#32; TiZrHfSc  &#32; As-cast Plate-like-hcp 1-2 RT 1001 \[14\]  As-cast  &#32;+ heat- treated  Plate-like-hcp 1-3 RT 800 \[16\]  As-cast Plate-like-hcp 2-3.5 RT 698 \[17\]  &#32; TiZrHfAlSc  &#32; Rolled and  heat- treated  Plate-like-hcp 0.1-0.5 400 1174 This  study 600 1265  As-cast Plate-like -hcp 0.3-0.8 RT 1450 \[19\] and high temperature. The strength of bcc-TiZrHfAl \[16\] was compared with that of hcp-491  TiZrHfAl. Their strengths were almost the same, even with the difference in crystal 492  structure and the volume fraction of Zr2Al.  493  For TiZrHfAlSc alloy with a plate-like structure, only room temperature strength was 494  reported in \[19\]. The high strength at room temperature indicates the significant effect of 495  the atomic size misfit as well as our high-temperature results. 496  &#32;In Table 7, the strength of TiZrHfSc \[16\] at room temperature is also shown. The 497  strength varied between 700 and 1000 MPa, which may be due to the difference in the 498  thickness of the martensite plate. The finer structures correlate to higher strength levels. 499  Compared with the strength of TiZrHfAl and TiZrHfSc, the strength of TiZrHfAl at 400 500  and 600 °C were similar value with the strength of TiZrHfSc at room temperature. The 501  average atomic size misfit (δ) is 3.99 for TiZrHf, 4.26 for TiZrHfSc, and 4.79 for 502  TiZrHfAl. This suggests that Al more effectively enhances the average atomic size misfit 503  (δ), significantly boosting strength compared to Sc. 504  &#32;505  4\.3 Deformation mechanisms 506  Fig. 9 illustrates that the TiZrHfAl alloy possesses an exceptionally high stress 507  exponent of 18 at room temperature, substantially surpassing those in the range of 3 and 508  5 in many traditional Ti alloys \[40–42\]. Typically, a stress exponent above 8 indicates 509  precipitation strengthening \[40,43,44\]. The 6% volume fraction of Zr2Al was observed as 510  shown in Fig. 4(b), but the effect will be small due to the low volume fraction. It is 511  suggested that atomic-level chemical fluctuation occurs in high-entropy alloys \[45\]. This 512  disarray can result in short-range order where dissimilar atoms gather or clusters where 513  similar atoms gather at the atomic level. These compositional fluctuations potentially 514  hinder dislocation movement. Table 5 reveals that the activation volume for dislocation 515  motion in TiZrHfAl at room temperature is notably smaller, at 6.3 b3, much lower than 516  the standard hcp metals and alloys, which typically exhibited 25-35 b3 \[32–34\]. Similar 517  trends of low activation volumes are observed in other TiZrHf series high-entropy alloys, 518  such as the bcc-TiZrHfNb alloy with an activation volume of 4.3 b3 \[31\]. Wu et al. \[46\]  519  introduce an improved Laubsch model, suggesting that high-entropy alloys with smaller 520  activation volumes have a more pronounced contribution from short-range order effects. 521  Consequently, it is postulated that the elevated stress exponent in the TiZrHfAl alloy 522  could be attributed to dislocations navigating through small obstacles like atomic clusters 523  in a short-range order, leading to a higher stress exponent and a reduced activation volume. 524  At 600°C, the TiZrHfAl alloy exhibits a stress exponent of 4.8, suggesting dislocation 525  slip as the predominant deformation mechanism, like that in traditional solid-solution-526 strengthened alloys \[41,42\]. Notably, there is an increase in activation volume at 600°C 527  compared to room temperature, aligning with the activation volumes found in typical hcp-528  type Ti and Mg metals at room temperature. This indicates that the small obstacles, like 529  the cluster of irregular atoms effective at room temperature, offer less resistance at 600°C. 530  Cross slip, frequently observed in standard hcp alloys such as hcp-Ti and Mg, which show 531  similar activation volumes to the TiZrHfAl alloy at 600 ℃, may also be a plausible 532  mechanism in this alloy. Furthermore, reports indicate that titanium alloys display lower 533  critical resolved shear stress (CRSS) values for both basal {0001} and prismatic {101̅0} 534  slip planes at 600 °C \[47\]. This finding corroborates the tendency of hcp-type alloys to 535  exhibit more cross-slip at elevated temperatures. 536  &#32;537  5 Conclusions 538  This study applied a thermomechanical process, including hot rolling and heat 539  treatment, to develop equiaxed hcp phases in TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and TiZrHfAlSc alloys. 540  High-temperature mechanical properties were assessed using compression tests, with a 541  focus on the deformation mechanisms in the TiZrHfAl alloy. Key findings include: 542  &#32;543  1\) Hot rolling at 1000 °C and heat treatment at 800 °C resulted in the formation of 544  equiaxed dual hcp structures about 1 μm in size in TiZrHfAl alloys, while TiZrHf 545  and TiZrHfAlSc alloys primarily formed plate-like hcp structures. 546  2\) The 0.2% proof stress of the alloys showed a consistent increase with the increase in 547  the mixing entropy ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥  and average atomic size misfit δ. Both TiZrHfAl and 548  TiZrHfAlSc alloys exhibited compressive strength exceeding 900 MPa at 600 ℃, 549  significantly surpassing conventional heat-resistant titanium alloys. 550  3\) The TiZrHfAl exhibits a high stress exponent of 18 and low activation volume at 551  room temperature, suggesting a mechanism of strengthening with interruption of 552  dislocation movement from minor obstacles such as atomic clusters or short-range 553  orders in HEAs. At 600 ℃, a lower stress exponent and larger activation volume 554  indicate that deformation is primarily due to dislocation slip, facilitated by cross slip. 555  &#32;556  Acknowledgments 557  This work was supported by Grants-in Aid for Transformative Research Area A, 558  21H05198 and The Light Metal Educational Foundation (Japan). We appreciate to Mr. 559  K. Iida, M. S. Iwasaki, Mr. M. Kobayashi in NIMS for rolling ingots. 560  &#32;561  Declaration of generative AI in scientific writing 562 During the preparation of this work, the authors used Grammary and ChatGPT in 563  order to improve the readability and language of this work. After using this tool, the 564  authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and took full responsibility for the 565  content of the publication. 566  &#32;567  Data Availablity 568  The raw/processed data required to reproduce these findings cannot be shared at 569  this time as the data also forms part of an ongoing study. 570  &#32;571  Reference 572  \[1\] C. (Christoph) Leyens, M. (Manfred) Peters, Titanium and titanium alloys : fundamentals and 573  applications, Wiley-VCH, 2003. 574  \[2\] M. Peters, J. Kumpfert, C.H. Ward, C. Leyens, Titanium Alloys for Aerospace Applications, 575  Adv Eng Mater 5 (2003) 419–427. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.200310095. 576  \[3\] K. SUZUKI, K. NAKAMURA, S. KATO, A. YAMAGISHI, Experimental Approach to 577  Obtain a Comprehensive Understanding of the Biogeochemistry of a Seafloor Hydrothermal 578  System, Chigaku Zasshi (Jounal of Geography) 118 (2009) 1131–1159. 579  https://doi.org/10.5026/jgeography.118.1131. 580  \[4\] J.-W. Yeh, S.-K. Chen, S.-J. Lin, J.-Y. Gan, T.-S. Chin, T.-T. Shun, C.-H. Tsau, S.-Y. Chang, 581  Nanostructured High-Entropy Alloys with Multiple Principal Elements: Novel Alloy Design 582  Concepts and Outcomes, Adv Eng Mater 6 (2004) 299–303. 583  https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.200300567. 584  \[5\] E.P. George, D. Raabe, R.O. Ritchie, High-entropy alloys, Nat Rev Mater 4 (2019) 515–534. 585  https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-019-0121-4. 586  \[6\] R.-X. Li, J.-W. Qiao, P.K. Liaw, Y. Zhang, Preternatural Hexagonal High-Entropy Alloys: A 587  Review, Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letters) 33 (2020) 1033–1045. 588  https://doi.org/10.1007/s40195-020-01045-9. 589  \[7\] J. Liu, X. Guo, Q. Lin, Z. He, X. An, L. Li, P.K. Liaw, X. Liao, L. Yu, J. Lin, L. Xie, J. Ren, 590  Y. Zhang, Excellent ductility and serration feature of metastable CoCrFeNi high-entropy 591  alloy at extremely low temperatures, Sci China Mater 62 (2019) 853–863. 592  https://doi.org/10.1007/s40843-018-9373-y. 593  \[8\] Z. Zhang, M.M. Mao, J. Wang, B. Gludovatz, Z. Zhang, S.X. Mao, E.P. George, Q. Yu, R.O. 594  Ritchie, Nanoscale origins of the damage tolerance of the high-entropy alloy CrMnFeCoNi, 595  Nat Commun 6 (2015) 10143. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms10143. 596  \[9\] D. Li, C. Li, T. Feng, Y. Zhang, G. Sha, J.J. Lewandowski, P.K. Liaw, Y. Zhang, High-597  entropy Al0.3CoCrFeNi alloy fibers with high tensile strength and ductility at ambient and 598 cryogenic temperatures, Acta Mater 123 (2017) 285–294. 599  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2016.10.038. 600  \[10\] O.N. Senkov, G.B. Wilks, J.M. Scott, D.B. Miracle, Mechanical properties of 601  Nb25Mo25Ta25W25 and V20Nb20Mo20Ta20W20 refractory high entropy alloys, 602  Intermetallics (Barking) 19 (2011) 698–706. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2011.01.004. 603  \[11\] W. Zhang, P. Liaw, Y. Zhang, A Novel Low-Activation VCrFeTaxWx (x = 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 604  and 1) High-Entropy Alloys with Excellent Heat-Softening Resistance, Entropy 20 (2018) 605  951\. https://doi.org/10.3390/e20120951. 606  \[12\] O.N. Senkov, J.M. Scott, S.V. Senkova, D.B. Miracle, C.F. Woodward, Microstructure and 607  room temperature properties of a high-entropy TaNbHfZrTi alloy, J Alloys Compd 509 608  (2011) 6043–6048. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2011.02.171. 609  \[13\] A. Takeuchi, K. Amiya, T. Wada, K. Yubuta, W. Zhang, High-Entropy Alloys with a 610  Hexagonal Close-Packed Structure Designed by Equi-Atomic Alloy Strategy and Binary 611  Phase Diagrams, JOM 66 (2014) 1984–1992. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11837-014-1085-x. 612  \[14\] T. Huang, H. Jiang, Y. Lu, T. Wang, T. Li, Effect of Sc and Y addition on the microstructure 613  and properties of HCP-structured high-entropy alloys, Applied Physics A 125 (2019) 180. 614  https://doi.org/10.1007/s00339-019-2484-1. 615  \[15\] S. Wang, D. Wu, H. She, M. Wu, D. Shu, A. Dong, H. Lai, B. Sun, Design of high-ductile 616  medium entropy alloys for dental implants, Materials Science and Engineering: C 113 (2020) 617  110959\. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2020.110959. 618  \[16\] Y. Yamabe-Mitarai, K. Yanao, Y. Toda, I. Ohnuma, T. Matsunaga, Phase stability of Ti-619  containing high-entropy alloys with a bcc or hcp structure, J Alloys Compd 911 (2022) 620  164849\. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2022.164849. 621  \[17\] Ł. Rogal, F. Czerwinski, P.T. Jochym, L. Litynska-Dobrzynska, Microstructure and 622  mechanical properties of the novel Hf25Sc25Ti25Zr25 equiatomic alloy with hexagonal 623  solid solutions, Mater Des 92 (2016) 8–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.11.104. 624  \[18\] S. Uporov, S.Kh. Estemirova, V.A. Bykov, D.A. Zamyatin, R.E. Ryltsev, A single-phase 625  ScTiZrHf high-entropy alloy with thermally stable hexagonal close-packed structure, 626  Intermetallics (Barking) 122 (2020) 106802. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2020.106802. 627  \[19\] L. Rogal, P. Bobrowski, F. Körmann, S. Divinski, F. Stein, B. Grabowski, Computationally-628  driven engineering of sublattice ordering in a hexagonal AlHfScTiZr high entropy alloy, Sci 629  Rep 7 (2017) 2209. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-02385-w. 630  \[20\] T. Nagase, M. Todai, T. Nakano, Development of Ti–Zr–Hf–Y–La high-entropy alloys with 631  dual hexagonal-close-packed structure, Scr Mater 186 (2020) 242–246. 632  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2020.05.033. 633  \[21\] A. Takeuchi, K. Amiya, T. Wada, K. Yubuta, Dual HCP structures formed in senary 634 ScYLaTiZrHf multi-principal-element alloy, Intermetallics (Barking) 69 (2016) 103–109. 635  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2015.10.022. 636  \[22\] L. Rogal, Y. Ikeda, M. Lai, F. Körmann, A. Kalinowska, B. Grabowski, Design of a dual-637  phase hcp-bcc high entropy alloy strengthened by ω nanoprecipitates in the Sc-Ti-Zr-Hf-Re 638  system, Mater Des 192 (2020) 108716. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2020.108716. 639  \[23\] T. Nagase, M. Todai, P. Wang, S.-H. Sun, T. Nakano, Design and development of (Ti, Zr, 640  Hf)-Al based medium entropy alloys and high entropy alloys, Mater Chem Phys 276 (2022) 641  125409\. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchemphys.2021.125409. 642  \[24\] G.-Y. Gan, L. Ma, D.-M. Luo, S. Jiang, B.-Y. Tang, Influence of Al substitution for Sc on 643  thermodynamic properties of HCP high entropy alloy Hf0.25Ti0.25Zr0.25Sc0.25-xAlx from 644  first-principles investigation, Physica B Condens Matter 593 (2020) 412272. 645  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physb.2020.412272. 646  \[25\] D.F. Neal, Development of TIMETAL 834, Materials Design Approaches and Experiences as 647  Held during the TMS Fall Meeting (2001) 199–213. 648  \[26\] S. Venkadesan, P. Rodriguez, K.A. Padmanabhan, P.V. Sivaprasad, C. Phaniraj, Flow 649  transients during strain rate jump tests in a titanium-modified austenitic stainless steel, 650  Materials Science and Engineering: A 154 (1992) 69–74. https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-651  5093(92)90364-7. 652  \[27\] Z. Tobolová, J. Čadek, An interpretation of steady state creep, Philosophical Magazine 26 653  (1972) 1419–1428. https://doi.org/10.1080/14786437208220352. 654  \[28\] K. Shimagami, T. Ito, Y. Toda, A. Yumoto, Y. Yamabe-Mitarai, Effects of Zr and Si addition 655  on high-temperature mechanical properties and microstructure in Ti-10Al-2Nb-based alloys, 656  Materials Science and Engineering A 756 (2019) 46–53. 657  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2019.04.031. 658  \[29\] J.L.M. D. Caillard, Thermally activated mechanisms in crystal plasticity, Elsevier, 659  Amsterdam, 2003. 660  \[30\] R.J. Asaro, S. Suresh, Mechanistic models for the activation volume and rate sensitivity in 661  metals with nanocrystalline grains and nano-scale twins, Acta Mater 53 (2005) 3369–3382. 662  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2005.03.047. 663  \[31\] Y.X. Ye, Z.P. Lu, T.G. Nieh, Dislocation nucleation during nanoindentation in a body-664  centered cubic TiZrHfNb high-entropy alloy, Scr Mater 130 (2017) 64–68. 665  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2016.11.019. 666  \[32\] G. Sargent, H. Conrad, STRESS RELAXATION AND THERNIALLY ACTIVATED 667  DEFORMATION IN TITANIUM, Pergamon Press, Inc, 1969. 668  \[33\] B.R. Anne, M. Tanaka, T. Morikawa, Temperature Dependence of Activation Enthalpy for 669  Yielding in Bimodal Ti–6Al–4V, Mater Trans 60 (2019) 1828–1832. 670 https://doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.ME201902. 671  \[34\] H. Somekawa, C.A. Schuh, Effect of solid solution elements on nanoindentation hardness, 672  rate dependence, and incipient plasticity in fine grained magnesium alloys, Acta Mater 59 673  (2011) 7554–7563. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2011.08.047. 674  \[35\] H. Masuyama, K. Shimagami, Y. Toda, T. Matsunaga, T. Ito, M. Shimojo, Y. Yamabe-675  Mitarai, Microstructure Evolution and Creep Behavior of Near-α Ti Alloy Produced by 676  Thermomechanical Processing, Mater Trans 60 (2019) 2336–2345. 677  https://doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.MT-MAW2019010. 678  \[36\] R. Labusch, A Statistical Theory of Solid Solution Hardening, Physica Status Solidi (b) 41 679  (1970) 659–669. https://doi.org/10.1002/pssb.19700410221. 680  \[37\] L.A. Gypen, A. Deruyttere, Multi-component solid solution hardening, J Mater Sci 12 (1977) 681  1028–1033. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00540987. 682  \[38\] I. Toda-Caraballo, P.E.J. Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo, Modelling solid solution hardening in 683  high entropy alloys, Acta Mater 85 (2015) 14–23. 684  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2014.11.014. 685  \[39\] I. Toda-Caraballo, A general formulation for solid solution hardening effect in 686  multicomponent alloys, Scr Mater 127 (2017) 113–117. 687  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2016.09.009. 688  \[40\] H. Hofmann, G. Frommeyer, C. Derder, Creep mechanisms in particle strengthened α-689  Titanium–Ti2Co alloys, Materials Science and Engineering: A 245 (1998) 127–134. 690  https://doi.org/10.1016/S0921-5093(97)00714-4. 691  \[41\] H. MISHRA, D. SATYANARAYANA, T. NANDY, P. SAGAR, Effect of trace impurities on 692  the creep behavior of a near α titanium alloy, Scr Mater 59 (2008) 591–594. 693  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2008.05.009. 694  \[42\] Z.Y. Ma, R.S. Mishra, S.C. Tjong, High-temperature creep behavior of TiC particulate 695  reinforced Ti–6Al–4V alloy composite, Acta Mater 50 (2002) 4293–4302. 696  https://doi.org/10.1016/S1359-6454(02)00261-6. 697  \[43\] J.C. Gibeling, W.D. Nix, The description of elevated temperature deformation in terms of 698  threshold stresses and back stresses: A review, Materials Science and Engineering 45 (1980) 699  123–135. https://doi.org/10.1016/0025-5416(80)90218-9. 700  \[44\] K. Shimagami, S. Matsunaga, A. Yumoto, T. Ito, Y. Yamabe-Mitarai, Solid Solution 701  Hardening and Precipitation Hardening of α2-Ti3;Al in Ti-Al-Nb Alloys, Mater Trans 58 702  (2017) 1404–1410. https://doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.MAW201707. 703  \[45\] S. Yoshida, T. Ikeuchi, T. Bhattacharjee, Y. Bai, A. Shibata, N. Tsuji, Effect of elemental 704  combination on friction stress and Hall-Petch relationship in face-centered cubic high / 705  medium entropy alloys, Acta Mater 171 (2019) 201–215. 706 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2019.04.017. 707  \[46\] Z. Wu, Y. Gao, H. Bei, Thermal activation mechanisms and Labusch-type strengthening 708  analysis for a family of high-entropy and equiatomic solid-solution alloys, Acta Mater 120 709  (2016) 108–119. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2016.08.047. 710  \[47\] T.B. Britton, F.P.E. Dunne, A.J. Wilkinson, On the mechanistic basis of deformation at the 711  microscale in hexagonal close-packed metals, Proceedings of the Royal Society A: 712  Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 471 (2015). 713  https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2014.0881. 714  &#32; 715  &#32;716 Fig. 1 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 1.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537043\&guid=e544a369-d0dc-4e24-aa82-a33ce9cff056\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537043&guid=e544a369-d0dc-4e24-aa82-a33ce9cff056&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537043\&guid=e544a369-d0dc-4e24-aa82-a33ce9cff056\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537043&guid=e544a369-d0dc-4e24-aa82-a33ce9cff056&scheme=1)Fig.2 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig.2.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536984\&guid=1b8841af-e266-49dc-b261-f7ba50268005\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536984&guid=1b8841af-e266-49dc-b261-f7ba50268005&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536984\&guid=1b8841af-e266-49dc-b261-f7ba50268005\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536984&guid=1b8841af-e266-49dc-b261-f7ba50268005&scheme=1)Fig.3 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig.3.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536985\&guid=13f87790-cc2f-4f5a-ad5f-7f3472460d2b\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536985&guid=13f87790-cc2f-4f5a-ad5f-7f3472460d2b&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536985\&guid=13f87790-cc2f-4f5a-ad5f-7f3472460d2b\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536985&guid=13f87790-cc2f-4f5a-ad5f-7f3472460d2b&scheme=1)Fig.4 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig.4.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536986\&guid=1e044576-eaeb-4560-b3fc-a15ad5cdf15e\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536986&guid=1e044576-eaeb-4560-b3fc-a15ad5cdf15e&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536986\&guid=1e044576-eaeb-4560-b3fc-a15ad5cdf15e\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3536986&guid=1e044576-eaeb-4560-b3fc-a15ad5cdf15e&scheme=1)Fig. 5 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 5.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537022\&guid=bd8c60de-98d4-4020-b558-d4f5fe3ff5dc\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537022&guid=bd8c60de-98d4-4020-b558-d4f5fe3ff5dc&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537022\&guid=bd8c60de-98d4-4020-b558-d4f5fe3ff5dc\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537022&guid=bd8c60de-98d4-4020-b558-d4f5fe3ff5dc&scheme=1)Fig. 6 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 6.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537023\&guid=f87c2efe-21d9-4541-93d2-c533d8e4614f\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537023&guid=f87c2efe-21d9-4541-93d2-c533d8e4614f&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537023\&guid=f87c2efe-21d9-4541-93d2-c533d8e4614f\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537023&guid=f87c2efe-21d9-4541-93d2-c533d8e4614f&scheme=1)Fig. 7 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 7.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537024\&guid=485d9880-81e8-4002-b17f-86818b51ae92\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537024&guid=485d9880-81e8-4002-b17f-86818b51ae92&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537024\&guid=485d9880-81e8-4002-b17f-86818b51ae92\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537024&guid=485d9880-81e8-4002-b17f-86818b51ae92&scheme=1)Fig. 8 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 8.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537026\&guid=ae57c139-765d-4800-8c9e-3aa3ccb4981c\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537026&guid=ae57c139-765d-4800-8c9e-3aa3ccb4981c&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537026\&guid=ae57c139-765d-4800-8c9e-3aa3ccb4981c\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537026&guid=ae57c139-765d-4800-8c9e-3aa3ccb4981c&scheme=1)Fig. 9 Click here to access/download;Figure(s);Fig 9.tif[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537030\&guid=a379b7a1-3ac4-43c1-aa65-e54e0ad0f5c1\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537030&guid=a379b7a1-3ac4-43c1-aa65-e54e0ad0f5c1&scheme=1)[https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537030\&guid=a379b7a1-3ac4-43c1-aa65-e54e0ad0f5c1\&scheme=1](https://www2.cloud.editorialmanager.com/msea/download.aspx?id=3537030&guid=a379b7a1-3ac4-43c1-aa65-e54e0ad0f5c1&scheme=1)&#32; Highlights  &#32;  The equiaxed hcp phase was successfully formed in TiZrHfAl using the hot rolling process  and subsequent heat treatment.   The 0.2 % proof stress of TiZrHf, TiZrHfAl, and TiZrHfAlSc alloys at 400 and 600°C,  increased with the increase of the average atomic size misfit δ and the mixing entropy ∆𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑥.    The 0.2 % proof stress of TiZrHfAl with an equiaxed hcp structure at 400 and 600°C was  significantly higher than conventional heat-resistant titanium alloys.   The TiZrHfAl exhibits a high stress exponent of 18 and low activation volume at room  temperature, suggesting a mechanism of strengthening with interruption of dislocation  movement from minor obstacles such as atomic clusters or short-range orders in HEAs.   HighlightsDeclaration of interests    ☒ The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships  that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.    ☐ The authors declare the following financial interests/personal relationships which may be considered  as potential competing interests:    &#32;         Declaration of Interest Statement