Article The century-old picture of a nerve spike is wrong: filaments fire, before membrane

Subrata Ghosh ; Pushpendra Singh ORCID (National Institute for Materials Science) ; Jhimli Manna ; Komal Saxena (National Institute for Materials Science) ; Pathik Sahoo ORCID (National Institute for Materials Science) ; Soami Daya Krishnanda ; Kanad Ray ; Jonathan P. Hill SAMURAI ORCID (National Institute for Materials Science) ; Anirban Bandyopadhyay SAMURAI ORCID (National Institute for Materials Science)

Collection

Citation
Subrata Ghosh, Pushpendra Singh, Jhimli Manna, Komal Saxena, Pathik Sahoo, Soami Daya Krishnanda, Kanad Ray, Jonathan P. Hill, Anirban Bandyopadhyay. The century-old picture of a nerve spike is wrong: filaments fire, before membrane. Communicative & Integrative Biology. 2022, 15 (1), 115-120.
SAMURAI

Description:

(abstract)

In 1907, Lapicque proposed that an electric field passes through the neuronal membrane and transmits a signal. Subsequently, a “snake curve” or spike was used to depict the means by which a linear flat current undergoes a sudden Gaussian or Laplacian peak. This concept has been the accepted scenario for more than 115 years even appearing in textbooks on the subject. It was not noted that the membrane spike should have a cylindrical shape. A nerve spike having a dot shape on membrane surface cannot propagate through a cylindrical surface since it would dissipate instantaneously. A nerve spike should have the appearance of a ring, encompassing the diameter of a cylindrical axon or dendron. However, this subtle change has remarkable implications. Maintaining a circular form of an electric field is not easy, especially at the surface of an organic object. Here, we suggest that neuroscience could redefine itself if we accept that a nerve spike is not a localized 3D Gaussian or Laplacian wave packet, rather it is a 3D ring encompassing the diameter of a neural branch.

Rights:

Keyword: nerve spike, ion channel, neuron, neurophysiology

Date published: 2022-12-31

Publisher: Informa UK Limited

Journal:

  • Communicative & Integrative Biology (ISSN: 19420889) vol. 15 issue. 1 p. 115-120

Funding:

  • Asian Office of Aerospace Research and Development, [AOARD] FA2386-16-1-0003 (2016–2019)

Manuscript type: Publisher's version (Version of record)

MDR DOI:

First published URL: https://doi.org/10.1080/19420889.2022.2071101

Related item:

Other identifier(s):

Contact agent:

Updated at: 2024-11-13 12:30:37 +0900

Published on MDR: 2024-11-13 12:30:37 +0900

Filename Size
Filename The century-old picture of a nerve spike is wrong filaments fire before membrane.pdf (Thumbnail)
application/pdf
Size 1.88 MB Detail